Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jean Johnson's avatar

Just skimmed your article, and if I got the gist, you're taking on human gluttony. Particularly American gluttony. Toqueville spotted it in the 1800s when Europe watched our fledging democracy for signs of humanity and freedom. He returned to France with sad news: that Americans love of wealth ala the tobacco farmers, the looting of New England's resources, the dismissal of the natives, superseded high minded ideals. More's the pity that we still think the fancier car will do the trick, never mind that we won't have the wheel. Yet, always there are slivers of hope shafting through the grey miasma: take Mamdani for example--and Bernie for another...

stieltjestransform's avatar

"If you described the capabilities of even today’s AI systems to an adherent of the silent consensus five or ten years ago, they would probably have predicted that joblessness would be much higher now than it in fact is, and that human disempowerment writ large would be far further along than it actually is."

Economic diffusion and the "waking up" of the outside world are lagging indicators of the transformative impact of AI technology. You can instead read these events as being even further in favor of the "adherents of the silent consensus." After all, the fact that, even with this powerful and robust a collection of AIs, institutions and regular people have changed their behavior so little, bodes very poorly for their ability to adapt in a general sense. Not only will they be racing on foot against a car that's accelerating, but they seem groggy and tired from the get-go.

Again, ask yourself: which world is more likely to be a precursor for one that keeps humans in charge: 1. everyone closes their eyes and pretends it's business as usual, or 2. companies, executives, politicians, etc. see what's coming and react accordingly years in advance?

"It may simply be the case, for example, that fully autonomous corporations outcompete human enterprise altogether."

What does "may" mean here? Is it a serious contention of yours that they won't? Does this hedging language add anything beyond rhetoric, or what's the vision of a world in which we have superintelligent AI that somehow doesn't run companies better than humans?

"If they are right, our fight against the silent consensus will be all the more challenging."

This entire essay seems to engage in a (perhaps unintentional) equivocation between "the silent consensus as an empirical claim about the world" and "the silent consensus as a prospective vision for what the future should be." Several sentences, or even paragraphs, vacillate between the two in a way that will likely cause confusion in a reader. Untangling positive descriptions from normative analyses is critical to maintain epistemic rigor.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?